[or: what keeps me up at night]
As you will see in the next post, I think Planet Nine is really out there. But that doesn’t mean you should think it is out there. You might be skeptical. In fact, I would prefer that you were skeptical. I would prefer that you read the scientific paper, looking for potential flaws, caveats, and places where we might have been led astray. But, OK, I understand that the actual scientific paper is on the weighty side, so, rather than make you wade through it finding the potential piutfalls, instead, I will give you my top list of things that might be wrong.
As you will see in the next post, I think Planet Nine is really out there. But that doesn’t mean you should think it is out there. You might be skeptical. In fact, I would prefer that you were skeptical. I would prefer that you read the scientific paper, looking for potential flaws, caveats, and places where we might have been led astray. But, OK, I understand that the actual scientific paper is on the weighty side, so, rather than make you wade through it finding the potential piutfalls, instead, I will give you my top list of things that might be wrong.
First, though: what is not
wrong.
If there is an
approximately 10 Earth mass planet on an extremely elliptical orbit in the
outer solar system, it would definitely line up the orbits of Kuiper belt
objects with similarly elongated orbits, it would create Kuiper belt objects with
orbits twisted by 90 degrees to the planets of the solar system, and it would
make objects, like Sedna, which have elongated orbits which don’t ever come
close to the rest of the Kuiper belt. These effects we now know from a general
mathematical analysis and from detailed computer simulations to double-check
the mathematical analysis. This analysis, I am confident to say, is iron-clad.
Astronomers will try to reproduce it (I hope), and they will get the same
results (I know). There truly is no wiggle room here. A 10 Earth mass planet
does exactly all of the things that we are trying to explain.
If I am so confident of this, how could Planet Nine possibly
not exist? Just because Planet Nine can explain all of these effects, it
doesn’t not mean that there is no other possible explanation. We tried to think
of everything that we could, and systematically ruled out alternatives, but
that doesn’t mean that someone else won’t come up with an idea that works.
Again, I hope that there are skeptical astronomers working right now to come up with alternatives. I am confident that they
will not come up with them (because I do actually think we considered
everything that could possibly be out there), but, unlike my statement above, I
will definitely not say that this one is iron-clad. Aluminum-clad, maybe.
Stainless steel, perhaps. I’d be willing to bet a lot of money against the idea
that someone will find an alternative explanation for all of the effects that
we are seeing. But it is possible I could lose.
There is one insidious way in which we may have been fooled
into thinking that Planet Nine exists, however, and it is a problem that
permeates all of experimental science. My single biggest worry is that perhaps –
just perhaps -- we have been fooled into seeing a pattern where none exists.
Humans excel at recognizing patterns, even when they are not there (see:
everything single face-on-Mars claim ever, for example). Could we have been
similarly fooled? Absolutely (again: I don’t think we have been, for reasons
detailed in that next post, but is it possible? Of course). Here’s how:
In our analysis, we show that the six most distant objects
that have orbits extending outward from the Kuiper belt all line up within a
100 degree quadrant and all have orbital planes which are tilted away from the plane
of the planets by about 20 degrees (and within 6 degrees of each other). From
some very simple calculations we can show that the probability of these
alignments happening due to chance is only about 0.007%. You could also say
that there is a 99.993% chance that the alignments we are seeing in the outer
solar system are real, and that we are not simply being fooled into seeing a
pattern where none exists.
But, really, if you said that, you’d be wrong. Real
statistics don’t work that way. You can’t, for example, flip 100 coins, realize
that 10 of them in the far upper right corner all turned up heads and then say
“wow; the chances of 10 heads in the far upper right corner is only one in 1024
so something must be happening up there.” And if you flipped all of the coins
again, chances are you wouldn’t get 10 heads in the far upper right corner (in
fact, chances are 1 in 1024). The real statistical question that you should be
asking at the first coin flip is more like “what is the probability that
something that seems anomalous will appear just due to chance?” That question
is essentially impossible to answer, because it relies on knowing what a human
who is looking for anomalous patterns would call anomalous.
There are two good ways to combat these sorts of flawed
statistics. The first I just mentioned above: replicate the experiment and look
for the same result. Your eye and brain might pick out a random pattern from
the noise one time, but the same pattern will not occur again. You might see
different patterns, but that just shows you how easy it is to find patterns in
data.
How do we replicate the finding that the most distant
objects in the outer solar system are unusually aligned? We find more of them.
If the alignment was just random pattern finding by easily fooled humans, it
will quickly go away when the next half dozen objects are discovered. And while
it took 12 years to discover the first 6 aligned objects, the next few should
be much faster, as telescopes and surveys continue to get bigger and more
powerful. One caveat: our computer simulations do not predict that 100% of the
most distant objects will be clustered. Just the vast majority. So finding one
or two outside of the cluster is not the end of Planet Nine. But finding the
next six objects randomly distributed around the sky would be a pretty clear
indication that we fell into the pattern-matching trap and that Planet Nine is
a fantasy. The Planet Nine hypothesis makes strong predictions, and these can
be used to show that the hypothesis is wrong, if it is.
The second way to combat the flawed statistics of pattern
matching is to use your explanation for the pattern that you see to predict
something entirely unrelated to the pattern. In our example of the coins above,
you could hypothesize that the explanation for all of the coins coming up heads
in one spot on the table is that there is a powerful magnetic field in that one
location of the table (ok, I’m not sure how that could make things come up all
heads, but work with me on this one). You could then make predictions. Perhaps
you would predict that a set of ball bearings placed on the table would
systematically roll towards that location. Or something. The key is that the
prediction is something that you don’t know the answer to ahead of time, is not
directly related to your original observation, and has a low probability of
occurring on its own. Here you are not replicating the experiment but are
instead performing a different experiment and predicting a very specific
answer.
Our hypothesis passed this test with flying colors – in my
opinion – with the prediction and subsequent realization of the existence of
what we call the distant twisted orbits (maybe we need a better term for these;
definitely we need a better term for these). But maybe it’s all just a bigger
case of pattern matching? Such an explanation begins to get unlikely, but now
we have a second set of objects that can be replicated, and we’ll all be
watching the results come in.
There is one other more mundane in which we can be “wrong.”
Given the small number of objects and our, currently, limited number of
computer simulations (“limited” here still means ~6 months of super computer
time, but we haven’t had time to precisely explore all of the possible
parameters of Planet Nine), it is possible that our estimates are not precisely
correct. Maybe Planet Nine js 20 times the mass of the Earth instead of 10.
Maybe it is actually a giant terrestrial planet instead of a small gas giant.
Maybe it is slightly further away or tilted into a slightly different plane.
These tweaks are OK. We would still say
that the Planet Nine hypothesis is correct.
If, however, a planet is found beyond Neptune and it is
totally different from what we have described, if it exists, but it fails to
cause the basic gravitational interactions that we have discussed, then, quite
simply, we are wrong. We are not predicting that there is some planet beyond Neptune, we are predicting that there is this planet beyond Neptune and it is
causing these effects on the outer
solar sytem.
Now, finally, is what you can tell your friends and family
to impress them by your informed skepticism of the Planet Nine hypothesis:
“I worry that they have underestimated the likelihood of
finding an intriguing pattern in the orbital data and that they have just been
fooled into finding a pattern where there is none. I am waiting for the next
few discoveries of distant object to see if they, too, have aligned and twisted
orbits like the theory demands. And, for now, I am also running some computer
simulations to check some ideas I have about other ways that the patterns can develop.
Ask me again in six months.”
Out of curiosity, do you have the simulation code available anywhere?
ReplyDeleteThis would be very helpful for both: verification by scientists and a learning experience for people who never even seen simulations like that.
DeleteWe run everything using the very standard mercury N-body simulation code as found, for example, here:
Deletehttp://www.arm.ac.uk/~jec/home.html
The ninth planet does exist. It already has a name, its Pluto. With the findings of the recent Pluto fly-by Pluto acts more like a planet than some of our other 8 planets. So I guess we are searching for the tenth planet. This planet, should it exist, is so far away that it is in perpetual darkness and unless it has a sizeable hot core its surface is frozen solid as well as the gases, if they are any, of the atmosphere. So Nibiru, it is not. We might call it planet Sitchin if it is finally found because it will be as far out as he was.
DeleteIt is not a pseudoplanet of 'Nibiru'-type (enters the inner system) or 'Nemesis'-type (enters the Oort cloud). In fact, it both fails these ideas yet again and cuts down on their remaining gaps. (Though I must not that using myths on the one hand, and supposed extinction patterns on the other where there are none - see Alroy's autocorrelation analysis of the extinction record - seems failed at the outset. (O.o))
DeleteNor is it a pseudoplanet of the more conventional "disturbance" type of Vulcan (Mercury)/Planet X (Neptune type). Pluto was one of those, but the very basis for the claim is also gone. It has been proposed to use the observed clearing of the orbit - which is necessary for old planets, but also is seen in systems with remaining disks - to unify definitions of our planets with exoplanets.
If you insist to call a miniature body for 'planet', it is either not relating to astronomical classifications (astrophysicists do this all the time) or it is for personal sentimental reasons. Go ahead, break a mirror (or whatever astronomers say)! ;-)
Great post.
ReplyDeleteAre there any two-planet explanations for the behavior of the KBO's?
None currently required. But not impossible.
DeleteM42 and our Sun with planets from X aphelia cca 300AU in right scale http://senmut.webs.com/nibiruorbitcarpetplanets.gif
ReplyDeleteactually the same is also on: http://senmut.webs.com/nibirubigsenmutchinabig.gif because this is also YGGDRASIL-WORLD TREE from nordic legends,..
Hi,...finaly it is out,....what I supposed too 12years ago,... http://senmut.webs.com/nibirucrosstext.gif … When I made also simulations in WINORSA nobody wanted to believe,... Pavel Smutny
You can find by me proposed coordinates also in this discussion: http://www.universetoday.com/29083/constraining-the-orbits-of-planet-x-and-nemesis/
ReplyDeletehttp://www.lulu.com/shop/pavel-smutny/ancient-egypt-and-2012/paperback/product-16951885.html
maybe my the most big mistake was too big mass of X in simulations,... but not of Nemesis,...
Is that 'Nemesis' of the extinction pattern search idea? Alroy rejected that with more fossil data and better statistical methods (autocorrelation analysis) already 2008 (IIRC; a PNAS paper I'm quite sure). Also, see my response to Brig why this makes it so much harder for this type of ideas if Planet Nine is found.
DeleteNames have meaning, so if you don't mean the arguably failed idea of 'Nemesis' you may better stick to "Planet X".
http://spaceweather.com/images2016/27jan16/cosmicrays_mar15_jan16.png?PHPSESSID=0eejd9rr5qmf39bhu10h5pab51 isnt it signal that something is closer to perihelia than year ago,..? http://senmut.webs.com/cosmic-ray-hot-spots.jpg
Deletehttp://senmut.webs.com/nibirueclipticorion.GIF
Nobody else gave explanation for where are those cosmic rays hot spots whereas from,..?! Nemesis 26000years orbit time, X 1300-2100years orbital time,... If you can give your explanations for where are those hot spots from Milagro cosmic rays survay from,..
I think that it is very important to explain right, where are those cosmic hot spots next to Orion (on both sides) from. Though are those hot spots places where from during mainly Spring and Outumn equinoxes are coming cosmic rays-mainly hi eccelerated protons from (X), or what else? If you want to find something, so it is good to look with telescopes, infrared telescopes on those hot spots. Especially on right hot spot-its prolongation during this Spring eqinox,....
DeletePavel Smutny
Many thanks for the great teaching on probability and stats, Mike, and on being an exemplar of the scientific method. It's helped me a lot, quite apart from anything to do with Planet Nine.
ReplyDeleteOh, BTW, as your resident proof-reader, for "wade through it finding the potential piutfalls," I suggest, "wade through it finding the potential pitfalls,"
Just a thought. Unless you feel strongly about piutfalls, which does have a nice ring to it. ;-)
If any scientist were to do a peer review of this paper would they also need 6 months super-computer time to verify the results?
ReplyDelete(also, I'd like to point out that the paper WAS peer reviewed before it was published, of course!)
DeleteI have heard some scientists say there wasn't enough gas out there to slow Planet Nine down enough to go into orbit.
ReplyDeleteIf I understood it correctly, Planet Nine was first put on a very eccentric orbit by Jupiter or Saturn, not fully ejected. It would have returned into the region of the giant planets, but one of the Sun's sibling stars that was passing by accelerated it enough so its new orbit never went back into the inner system.
DeleteBeing ejected from the inner Solar System to ~1000AU does not require ejection from the outer Solar System (~70000AU). You just need a method to "lift the perihelion point" after being kicked outwards.
DeleteDefinitely an open question!
DeleteMy interest is astrobiology, so this open question is highly interesting. I hope people will work on the mechanisms and timing until PN can be tested as a planet observation. (Shades of Kepler's "candidate" vs "confirmed".)
DeleteWhen Batygin hypothesized early ejection, and settling due to other system's influences in Sun's birth cluster rather than drag effects, it puts the question front and center for me. Same as PN there is now a "candidate" fossil that dates to before 4.1 Ga, and Valley's latest zircon review (2015) predicts a habitable ocean before 4,.3 Ga. At the same time that this is in tension with a late bombardment, no zircons older than 3.5 Ga show the typical impact fracture patterns seen at e.g. Vredesfort at ~ 2 Ga.
If an early ejection - which plays nice with the Nice model - could be tied to the Nice model's Jupiter/Saturn resonance in time, the tension would go away. The early Oort cloud could have been developing and compact for much the same reason that kept Planet Nine in the system. Perhaps the Moon impact record (which hinges on absence of contamination re dating) is integrated over the long tail of the disk clearing. (Someone with impact chops may work on that too! X's fingers.)
A series of circumstances, but so are the late bombardment mechanism...
The problem is that it is now totally impossible to simulate the formation of our solar system and all of the interactions (internal and external) that have occurred since its inception.
ReplyDeleteWhat we can do, however, is begin to consider the idea that our solar system was at least initially part of a binary system, and that the anomalies we observe are in part due to the complexities of binary solar system development.
All of our mythologies tell us that this was indeed the case (although the twin may no longer be with us). In myth, there is both a 12th/"Benjamin"/"Horus" planet (which could be Brown's "Planet 9" or simply Sedna and its ETNO "followers"), AS WELL AS a failed twin/"Esau"/"Apophis" star that "separated" from our own "Jacob/Atum-Re" star under influence of a large "Laban" star.
I applaud Mike's efforts to find more objects and for continuing to push the issue despite the lackluster support from his colleagues.
http://www.domainofman.com/boards/index.php?topic=128.0
The solar system wasn't formed, it was created by God about 6,000 years ago. Short period comets prove a young solar system. And there are many other proofs.
DeleteI would like to see an animation of two objects in an anti-aligned resonant orbit.
ReplyDeleteI don,t follow all the complex maths but wonder if we can rule out the 20* inclination as being due to pertubation from a passing star or even capture of these distant objects from a smaller star ?
ReplyDeleteNO: it could be true.
DeleteI have been wondering (from a layperson standpoint, not as a scientist) – Sedna and these other objects whose clustering appears to indicate the existence of Planet Nine are all near(ish) perihelion, correct? This, I imagine, is one of the reasons making it easier to discover them, since it’s easier to observe them near perihelion than when further away. However, given the extreme difference between the length of their orbits in comparison to the length of time we had the technology to observe such objects – there is a selection bias towards only observing those objects that are near perihelion.
ReplyDeleteCould there be far more objects like this with vastly different orbits, just we haven’t found them yet because they are far enough form perihelion that they are hard to detect? So in a sense – once we have a “complete” picture of these objects, could there appear to be no clustering at all – just the clustering we saw is because of a relatively limited window in time and detection capability?
Of course, I wondered if there are more of these with orbits all over the place – why aren’t any of them near perihelion now? Which got me wondering about a more complex idea (that is probably entirely wrong, again, I’m not a scientist). :)
Could it be that all of these distant objects are gathered together in similar but separate clusters? Perhaps with the vastly complex gravitational effects of a large number of these objects, they might self-organize into multiple clusters resonating with each other. So, if the “Planet Nine Cluster” has perihelion at 9:00 radially, then there is another cluster that is near aphelion right now that has perihelion at 3:00, and so on for 6 clusters or 10 clusters, or some such. (I imagine it’s a low number, because too many and some others would be near perihelion as well).
I know you checked for some self-organizing, but is it feasible/possible that with these objects, they are clustered close enough that their combined gravitational effect (and I will throw in maybe some hand-wavey resonance) creates the observed effect? So maybe there is a significant amount of mass out there in these objects, but it is in separate, small objects away from perihelion (and therefore difficult to see) but clustered somewhat near enough to each other that their gravitational effects can build up. (I’m reminded of pushing kids on a merry-go-round – a lot of little pushes timed right can work as well as fewer, bigger pushes).
Sorry, that wound up being longer than I expected and if I knew my astronomy better is probably full of holes. But it’s fun to theorize about possibilities. Good luck in being proven right! It is an exciting time.
There has been no other responses yet, so from a layman to another, I too considered the potential for a selection bias and so could reference your comment in mine further down the thread.
DeleteSo this is for the astronomers, but I think the paper (which I only browsed) claims the Kuiper Belt mass is too small for a clumping making the putative shepherding. Then it is hard to envisage clumping of any kind in the neighborhood, at a guess.
Question: Unless I've calculated the wrong thing, a New Horizons range signal for a Planet Nine with mass = 5mE and distance = 1000 AU would be about 500 times stronger than the one predicted for a 0,7mE object in a distance of 4500 AU, so as soon as it is on the correct course without the need of course correction (which would disturb the signal) it should be picked up much faster than the six years needed in Iorio's prediction.
ReplyDeleteAm I very wrong here? (And if not, are you already in contact with Iorio?)
And would accurately measuring the range signal be possible while New Horizons is still in the middle of sending Pluto system data back to Earth?
DeleteMostly I think NH is going the wrong direction. But it is worth looking into.
DeleteIt's near the opposite direction. But it would measure the difference of the effects Planet Nine has on Earth/Sun on one side and New Horizons on the other anyway. I think the worst case would be at right angle, but according to your treasure map Planet Nine would have already been found if it was there.
DeleteDid some back-of-the-envelope calculation with a simple acceleration formula, and now I get 3 meters after one year (44 EP9 - 41 NHP9) and 12 after two, for 5mE at 1000 AU distance - more if closer or heavier, of course. Still detectable, but not as good and fast as I thought from my shortcut. Hm.
DeleteCould "Planet Nine" be already found? Could those clustered objects be the remnants of a Planet Nine break-up or collision that happened some many Gyrs ago?
ReplyDeleteNope; they are clustered in perihelion, but with very different orbits. Not like a collision.
DeleteI've been studying the Moon with my Canon sr60x. I think I see telescopes there, at least long, cylindrical objects. Some of the telescopes align thus are probably looking at the same thing. Perhaps it is Planet 9 or Niburu? Whatever it is it is not in the planetary plane. It is southwesterly. Check my facebook site at "Life on Mars and the Moon", for a photo of what I am writing about.
ReplyDeleteIf planet IX exists maybe it was ejected with planetesimals and created their various orbits? The planet itself was too big to slow down and stay in the solar system.
ReplyDeleteWISE did not find Tyche
The "look elsewhere" effect - which traditionally only look for one pattern, but that is a start for quantifying it - is mooted in particle physics by increasing the quality limit from 3 sigma to 5 sigma. (Or as I just listened on a recent SETI talk, in Kepler planet search, which has some of the same problems, by going to 7 sigma.)
ReplyDeleteSo this explanation of that adding the 5 distant twisted orbits is pending is good to hear. Meanwhile I tried to estimate by two independent means, which seem to check out. Naively extrapolation puts the combined likelihood of being random data in the neighborhood of the required 1 in a million. And so does a simple binomial yes/no combo of 11 distant orbits with 2 independent orbit parameters. (Say, longest axis and one "twist" angle.)
[I would love to add the known phase of the orbiting bodies, but as Ken says in a previous comment, it can be a selection bias of observation capability.]
So I think it could be a real observation, not a result of excessive pattern search.
Thankyou eversomuch for this blog; it's a real privilege to see thoughts and musings from the professional astronomers at the center of the recent news. I for one am hoping that as many telescopes as possible can join the hunt.
ReplyDeleteDuring these early days there are lots of names being suggested... my personal fave is 'Nox' being the Roman equivalent of Nyx, goddess of the night.
Good luck to all involved.
My thanks too for sharing this moment.
ReplyDeleteA paranoid thought: If Mike's P9 suddenly disappeared, snatched at aphelion, how fast would the orbit-clustering of opposing bodies "decay"? And sorry if that was covered in the papers I havent read yet...
~100 million years
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIs the new planet at around 358.4 AU from the sun?
ReplyDeletemaybe?
DeletePlanet nine reminds me the planet of Dumusque in Alpha Centauri B. I wonder if these clustered KBOs are a bias due to the strategy of detection as well.
ReplyDeleteIf, as many believe, something seems to be perturbing the outer planetary objects and it is not Planet 9 and assuming that it cannot be our mythical dead twin-sun `Nemesis’ which as yet has never been found (if indeed it ever existed it perhaps should be a lot further out), then what is the cause – an anomaly with the data or can it be anything else?
ReplyDeleteNemesis is an obsolete idea from the 1980s. The clustering could be the result of a massive belt of objects even further out. But I still prefer the P9 concept as it is a cleaner explanation.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteAgreed. I also see the logic in the existence of Planet 9 but it is always wise and best practice to eliminate all other possibilities (even the most obvious) and subject the theory to close scrutiny before emotionally accepting the hypothesis. At the moment I also seem to be in the Planet 9 camp - but I'm sure that there is a lot more work to be done...
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteQuestion: What exactly is meant when you say Sedna would be back in the Kuiper belt eventually? An orbit like "Buffy"? Or a closer orbit? Or a still-excentric orbit, just with a much closer aphelion? What did the simulations show?
ReplyDeleteperihelion back int he Kuiper belt.
DeleteHmm...I'm a bit skeptical about finding planets 9, right now was found when the largely about Planet X...whether it is a coincidence??? Mr.Mike Brown???
DeleteSo, when planet 9 is finally confirmed, how will that info be released? Here, big press conference....?
ReplyDeleteIs there a Nineth Planet out there? YES.
ReplyDeleteIs this planet exactly as described by astronomers? NO, but completely diffrent. for example: if they said it,s cold, the truth is hot. far away, the truth isn't far away. that's because they try to be smarter than the God.
Thank you for sharing such a decent post
ReplyDeleteBrother Printer Support
brother printer customer care phone number
Grab online thesis help from the experience writers of MyAssignmenthelp.com. Our writers are in huge numbers and all our years of expertise. That is why they know how to prepare student's academic papers. They also prepare their thesis paper as the requirements of student's universities and colleges. Get in touch with us today and enjoy submitting a unique thesis paper.
ReplyDeleteMy Assignment login or Assignment Help Australia are among the many services that Assignment Studio has to offer. The best assignment help in Australia by the in-house qualified and expert writers to the local and international students in Australia, so that scoring top-notch grades does not pose a problem for them
ReplyDeleteOnline Biology Paper Writing Services produces different assignments, including Buy Essay Online Services, to help students deal with the Buy Business Reports challenges they face every day.
ReplyDeleteLooking for essay help online?. Want essay assignment help? Let’s have a look at our endeavors! MyAssignmenthelp AU have a range of professional writers ready to provide essay assignment help or essay help to the students presenting top quality essays, keeping in mind the instruction provided by their professors.
ReplyDeletePlanet nine always been a surprise to scientists. Maybe we step on planet nine like moon and other planets. By: Buy dissertation online
ReplyDeleteComputers have penetrated in our daily life stream and now all our daily operations are dominated by this man made machine. The reshaping of computers has made it possible for ordinary men master his own computer. This is an era of widespread computing, which will be characterized by one individual-to-many computers, dominated by handheld, intelligent, and everyday devices with embedded technology and connectivity. Benefit from professional computer assignment help by our expert writers based in Australia.
ReplyDeleteour team is professional and do work according the requirement. our team customize the Custom boxes according your requirement and print your logo on the boxes.it will main be helped someone
ReplyDeletelipstick boxes
cosmetic box packaging
Avail my assignment help Australia service by hiring our expert academic writers who have the knowledge, skills and experience to help college and university students with their research papers, essays, case studies and Thesis projects.
ReplyDeleteOnline assignment help
Case Study help
Urgent Assignment help
Essay help online
Assignment help
This online essay writing service gives 24 hours of accessibility to understudies. Through this, the understudies can at whatever point look for help from online associations.
ReplyDeleteonline homework help
get online assignment help
This is Arick Jhon from Packaging Mines.I am regular reader of your blog. Your thinking about your topic or a business strategy is absolutely right. I am reading your blog's every line and every point describe in a correct way .Thanks for giving me information. We are offering Cosmetic Packaging
ReplyDeletewith product designing by wholesale Prices
Your thinking about your topic or a business strategy is absolutely right. I am reading your blog's every line. This is Jones smith from get instant printing. I am regular reader of your blog. We are both in a same industry and every point describe in a correct way .Thanks for giving me information. We are offering Custom Printed Boxes with product designing by wholesale Prices.
ReplyDeletetanx very nice post very good
ReplyDeleteخرید رپورتاژ آگهی
Thanks for sharing this information. I have shared this link with others to keep posting such information to provide the best in class assignment help online at very affordable prices.
ReplyDeletefinance homework help online
finance assignment writing service
finance assignment writing
Finance Coursework Help
Financial Accounting Assignment Help
financial accounting homework help
accounting and finance assignment
assignment on financial accounting
Financial Planning Assignment Help
financial planning homework help
Law Assignment Help
help with law assignment
law homework help
Management Assignment Help
management assignment writing help
management assignment writing
management homework help
Marketing Assignment Help
online marketing assignment help
marketing assignment writing service
international marketing assignment help
online marketing assignment
marketing homework assignment
marketing homework help
I found this one pretty fascinating, and you should go into my collection also. We provide online statistics homework help services all over the world. I am impressed with your article. We appreciate that please keep writing more content.
ReplyDeleteI was able to find good info from your articles.
ReplyDeleteدانلود سریال قورباغه دانلود سریال قورباغه دانلود سریال قورباغه دانلود سریال قورباغه دانلود سریال قورباغه
nice post HostGator Shared Web Hosting Black Friday discount
ReplyDeleteDifferent people have different views about this topic because some people think that there are eight planets in the Universe while some think that there are nine planets because they think that Pluto is included in other planets. What is your opinion about it? Dissertation writing service.
ReplyDeleteExactly what i was looking for. It is no secret that people are often charged with more responsibility than what they signed up for in an organisation. At such a time, one cannot argue over the fact that they did not sign up for this. Consequently, universities prepare the students to work with a greater knowledge of Petroleum Engineering. For that, the assignments are targeted in a way that makes students go beyond the classroom knowledge. Get Petroleum Engineering Homework Help
ReplyDeleteOur service has been very supportive to our customers and especially in solving their problems and providing them with best boxes which are fully credible and worthy of their trust.
ReplyDeleteEyelash Boxes
Lipstick Boxes
custom book boxes,
sock packaging
Hi, this is a nice blog thanks for sharing the Informative blog content. I am Axel Smith from USA. I am working as a full-time academic consultant with Crazy For Study. we providing Physics Solution Manuals services in USA to university or students. I served the stressed students residing in USA for more than 7 years and hold excellent writing skills and provides guidance to academic scholars and students.
ReplyDeleteEveryone looking at some information ideas forms the different platform, If you shared some creative and informative ideas then the user is very loyal to read your blog. thanks for share highly valuable article with us. Geometry Textbook Solution Manual
ReplyDeleteI love this post. Thanks for sharing. You can also get custom sock boxes packaging also you visit us.
ReplyDeleteNice Post. Thanks for sharing. Keep sharing up
ReplyDeleteSocks Boxes Packaging
Best post!
ReplyDeleteCustom Bags
Bakery Boxes
Bottle Boxes
Candle Boxes
CBD Boxes
Sleeve Boxes
Food Boxes
The way you have described about Custom Packaging, Donut Boxes, Rigid Boxes, Candle Boxes, Shoe Boxes is great, every start up business should try to get Custom boxes for their product.
ReplyDeleteSwaray, is an independent rapper, singer, songwriter based out of Los Angeles, California. Swaray is giving artists a run for their money with not only his diverse catalog but lifestyle as well.
ReplyDeleteIf I am so confident of this, how could Planet Nine possibly not exist? Just because Planet Nine can explain all of these effects, it doesn’t not mean that there is no other possible explanation. We tried to think of everything that we could, and systematically ruled out alternatives, but that doesn’t mean that someone else won’t come up with an idea that works. https://www.harborcompounding.com/tag/1196-compounding-pharmacy
ReplyDeleteIf I am so confident of this, how could Planet Nine possibly not exist? Just because Planet Nine can explain all of these effects, it doesn’t not mean that there is no other possible explanation. We tried to think of everything that we could, and systematically ruled out alternatives, but that doesn’t mean that someone else won’t come up with an idea that works. A rise in endogenous oxytocin results in an increase of plasma endorphins, natural pain killers that can diminish pain in women who suffer dyspareunia , due to anxiety or lack of trust in their partner during the first stages of their relationship.
ReplyDeleteAre you looking for ayurvedic consultant then don’t worry we have best Ayurvedic Doctor in Australia
ReplyDeleteA Kansa wand is simply an answer to balance your body, your pH levels, your chakras and your doshas. Kansa wands have a longer history, associated with Ayurvedic practices. You can easily buy Kansa wand from our website.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteCorporate Finance emphasizes on the company's finances, financial position, and increasing the company's profits to clients in order to secure long-term profitability. Our professionals can assist you with corporate finance assignment if you are unable to complete assignment for any reason. In Australia's major cities, we have successfully provided well-written and excellent online assignment services. Visit now:- Corporate Finance Assignment Help
Boostupblog is the best guest post services provider. If you want to promote your business and get organic traffic for your website then Boostupblog is the best platform for you. Write quality content related to your business and you will get good results by using our platform.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteWe,Kickr Technology transforms mobile apps on various platforms and devices. We have a team of experts who works on various technologies and try to make app most downloadable app of play store.
Thank you for posting such a great article. Keep it up mate. custom packaging
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteHow to Log in to Ancestry DNA Account?
Colour Coding in FTM 2019
Honda navigation update
ReplyDeleteEvery user can update the honda navigation system with ease. All you have to do is follow some basic instructions, and you can update the honda Navi by yourself. Most of the time, customers ask whether their updates are free or paid.
We want to inform you that all Honda Navi updates are free of cost most of the time. A few times, the updates are paid if you have an older honda vehicle. Many times consumers end up paying a good amount of money to the local dealers. We want to inform you that you can get the updates for yourself without paying any additional fees or charges if you can follow some basic steps.
does planet nine really exist? time will tell of it, thanks for sharing. check free nitda scholarship past questions pdf
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhile the possibility of Planet Nine is intriguing, it's important not to forget about monitoring our own vital signs. Meri Sehat's online medical services offer convenience, accessibility, and certified doctors available 24/7. With affordable rates and patient satisfaction as their top priority, Meri Sehat is a game-changer in the field of online healthcare.
ReplyDeleteYour post describes all the needed information in a detailed manner. Keep posting more! Thanks for sharing this post! Worried about your online math classes in the US? Hire Someone To Take My Online Math Class at Greatassignmenthelp.com to get assured answers for every subjective query you are dealing with. Our professionals can assist you in completing your all tasks with quality work and improve your academic performance. You just need to use our writing services to obtain immediate assistance from well-experienced writers. Visit us now to know more details!
ReplyDelete