Pages

Sunday, January 24, 2016

The long and winding history of Planet X

Standing up in public and claiming that you have found evidence for a new planet in the solar system almost certainly means that you are about to join a century-long list of people who have been wrong. I mean, look, le Verrier and Adams did it in 1846 when they predicted the existence of Neptune, sure, but since then there have been dozens (hundreds?) of similar claims (including le Verrier himself, who thought he had found a Planet Vulcan inside the orbit of Mercury) which have all lead to absolutely nothing.

For most of the 160 years, astronomers tried to use the positions of the planets themselves to infer the existence of another planet (amusingly: it was the search for this alleged planet that led to the inadvertent discovery of Pluto, which is why the New York Times headline on the day of the Pluto announcement suggests that the planet might be bigger than Jupiter, which it is not).  This idea was finally put to rest in 1993, when a careful analysis of modern data showed that all of the planets are exactly where they are supposed to be (links to papers here may lead to irritating pay walls, but you can at least read the abstracts, I think).

When it was clear that the planets were where they were supposed to be, astronomers moved on to the comets, which traverse the regions where Planet X might be, and could be effected by them. A suggestions was made that Planet X causes comet showers  and modulates the positions of incoming comets, but these suggestions have rarely been given much credibility when more detailed analyses are performed.

The idea of trying to detect Planet X by its gravitational effects was re-picked up soon after the discovery of the Kuiper belt. Early on, astronomers proposed a Mars-like planet at ~60 AU to explain an apparently abrupt outer edge to the Kuiper belt, but then quickly ruled it out. But the idea kept floating around, and many papers suggested some sort of variant.

Things began to get interesting with the discovery of Sedna, which was the first object discovered in the solar system whose orbit could only be explained by interaction with something besides the known planets (I have a whole series on this over on my blog. Also, now I know how to end the series). In the discovery paper, I suggested, among other possibilities, a new planet. But a ~Earth sized one around 70 AU. Really, though, for the past 12 years I have been convinced that Sedna's strange orbit is a left over relic from the formation of the sun in a cluster of stars 4.5 billion years ago. Others suggested a ~Mars mass planet a little further out as the culprit, or even a planet that was once in the outer solar system, but is now gone. Planets are popular things to propose when you see some gravitational effect that you cannot otherwise explain.

After Sedna, the most interesting developments in the Planet-X-ology came from two papers over the past few years. First, Chad Trujillo and Scott Sheppard noted some unusual orbital alignments among distant Kuiper belt objects (arguments of perihelion appeared clustered around zero, to be specific). They proposed a ~2 earth mass planet at a few hundred AU organizing these objects through a mechanism called a Kozai resonance, though they pointed out in their own paper that they couldn't make the idea work out. And detailed simulations showed that their proposed planet did not have the hoped for effect and thus could not be real. Once again. Though this time, critically, the data looked good, just not the explanation.


A more recent study also had important clues about Planet Nine. In September, Rodney Gomes and colleagues proposed that an entirely separate set of objects were being influenced by some sort of distant planet. While they were not able to use the observations to say much about the planet, they concluded that it was likely that these objects were being pushed around by something large and far away.

So by this last September, then, if you were paying extremely close attention, you might have been clued in that something was going on in the outer solar system and that a large planet might well be a good explanation, but no one could figure out exactly what was going on. Was there some way to connect Sedna, the strange alignments of Trujillo and Sheppard, and the distant objects of Gomes et al?


This moment reminds me of the time right after the discovery of Uranus. In 1783, Anders Johan Lexell published the first calculation of the orbit of Uranus (proving that it was on an elliptical, rather than parabolic orbit, and thus not a comet). Lexell found that, while the orbit of Uranus was elliptical, it also appears to be being perturbed by an external body, presumably a planet. More detailed calculations of the orbit of Uranus in 1821 by Alexis Bouvard confirmed the orbital irregularities and reinforced the idea that there must be an eighth planet out there. These calculation are the ones that led Adams and le Verrier to separately try to see if they could figure out not just if there was a planet out there, but where there was a planet.

This point is where Konstantin and I started. We could tell that the data from Trujillo and Sheppard was right: something was happening in the outer solar system, but no one could quite figure out what (the paper by Gomes et al. hadn't been published yet, but would eventually be a critical part of the story). We quickly re-confirmed that the Kozai resonance hypothesis of Trujillo and Sheppard didn't work, so what was it? At this point you can read Konstantin's account of how we got to the answer. Are we right this time? After all of these years? We think so. The data are good, the understanding of how the gravitational forces push everything around is good. We think that, this time, we've actually identified something real out there. We're confident enough to stand up in public and say that we think we have found evidence for a new planet in the solar system.

And we think it is time to retire the long and winding history of Planet X, and start anew with Planet Nine.



89 comments:

  1. Thanks for a really helpful summary.

    BTW - you really don't like the second "n" in Konstantin, do you? Makes him sound like a medicine for high cholesterol...
    ("Konstatin's account")

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Google started using site speed as a ranking signal in their algorithm way back in 2010, and it continues to serve as one of the many factors that determine where your website shows up in the search results. We help you WordPress Speed Optimization are Page Caching, PHP latest version, Image optimization and resizing, jquery update, Cache Preloading, Sitemap Preloading, GZIP Compression, Browser Caching, Database Optimization, Google Fonts Optimization, Lazyload, Minifying JS CSS HTML files, Deferring Unused JS/CSS, CDN setup, Mobile Detection, Stop unused CSS and JS file and many more optimization your WordPress website. So, your website super-fast loading within 1-5 seconds. WordPress Speed Optimization

      Delete
  2. oy. Also, I can't spell in general.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Are the current models able to predict the approximate position of the proposed Planet 9 or just its orbital path? If it does suggest its likely current position, is it currently nearer its apogee or perigee in relation to the Sun?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Finding things you weren't looking for is the best feeling isn't it? So compelling but requires even more vigilance in the self fulfilling prophesy department.

    Do you have an expectation for the proportion of KBOs having detached orbits at any given time cf the whole population? If so, how does this stack up with the data?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, depends on assumptions about 4 billion year old events, so no honest predictionsm

      Delete
  5. I've compiled a small bibliography on the "history of Planet 9" from your post, including links to the full texts. (Mainly for myself, but I guess it may be of interest for someone else.)
    https://docs.google.com/document/d/1XEYQk1EuPs4dsJv280ZE6DmVn_h6y1PEBVxhA4AOVD8/pub

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The problem is we currently can only detect Sednoids when they are close to perihelion. They are simply too faint when far from it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. ~11300 years would correspond to a~500 AU, at the lower end of the range. I think twice that would fit better with the periods (and would correspond to a~800 AU), while 1.5 times would correspond with a~660 AU, which is closer to the chosen best-fit value of 700 AU.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm not an astronomer but could a rogue moon being thrown out of the system be a possible culprit for creating the orbit of Sedna and others? Was this a considered possibility?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It wouldn't be massive enough. The biggest a moon can be is the size of Mars, which is only 1/6th of Earth.

      Delete
  11. I'm not either, but, I think:
    this aligment required repetitive nudges over a long time from a heavy planet (>4 earths). A moon would be at least 10x lighter than that, and it would get only about one pass, being on an ejection trajectory as you suggest. So its effects would be hundreds of times too weak.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm not either, but, I think:
    this aligment required repetitive nudges over a long time from a heavy planet (>4 earths). A moon would be at least 10x lighter than that, and it would get only about one pass, being on an ejection trajectory as you suggest. So its effects would be hundreds of times too weak.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Presently a significant number of you will respond to this inquiry in a: What is he on about at this point? kind of route or in a condition of wariness or even bewildered. You will most likely reply: obviously Yashua Messiah (The Lord Jesus Christ) is God; in the event that He is not God then I, as a Christian, am still dead in my wrongdoings, for just God (complete flawlessness) as a penance would have been sufficient or culminate enough to take away every one of the transgressions of humanity. Symbol of Jesus Christ in the "Narnia" series

    ReplyDelete
  14. Actually, it's the 2nd Planet 9 because Planet X was also the 9th planet because it was started in 1919 by Lowell, long before Pluto was identified in '30 (it was actually discovered by Lowell, but he didn't identify it as such). It is a myth that the X meant 10, it really meant ''unknown'', obviously, but scientists love myths, like the myth of the gas giant, they're really liquid.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Madam Blavatsky was the one who names a Planet Vulcan. She never implied that Vulcan was near the Sun. In fact, she said that Vulcan was the 'Forge of the Avatars'. If one takes her seriously, one can come up with a body in a 4969 year orbit and inclined at 48.44 degrees. Oddly enough, U of Az asreonomers think that planet Nine's inclination is either 18 or 48 degrees.

    ReplyDelete
  16. TutuApp Apk is one of the best-paid app stores which allows you to download the paid apps for free. In tutu app Download, you will find hacked apps as well.

    ReplyDelete
  17. We are academic paper writing service in the Singapore and help to struggling students who won't be able to prepare their assignments, essays own. There are various reasons to not prepare assignment by their own like lack of skills, lack of attendance in college, a part-time job and many more reasons. And we can understand their problems and hence we provide them with online paper writing help.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Many students are undecided about the best nursing essay writing help company to deal with due to the high number of companies that offer similar services.

    ReplyDelete
  19. pauses and starts again, the solution is to first download it, and then you can play it from your desktop. Many people on the user showcase post on soundcloud. You can download songs from soundcloud using something like this soundcloud converter Just paste in the URL of the soundcloud song. And you get a mp3 download.

    ReplyDelete

  20. Buy custom white packaging boxes wholesale and it is an inspiring packaging solution for your product. custom packaging boxes with logo at the wholesale rate with free shipping costs all across the United States and Canada.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I have read your blog its very attractive and impressive. I like it your blog.
    email address lookup tips

    ReplyDelete
  22. Looking for houses and real estate in lahore. Go buy through this link. House for sale in dha lahore

    ReplyDelete
  23. As you know that Custom boxes is a lip care product and customers are very conscious about using such products because they will be cheap rate and well quality.lip balm boxes

    ReplyDelete
  24. Spot on with this write-up, I seriously believe this site needs a great deal more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the advice!

    KBC Official Website
    KBC Official Winner Website
    KBC Official Website
    KBC Official Website

    ReplyDelete
  25. We will discuss here about universe and planets. Some experts think that there are ten planets but planet X has not yet been discovered, and there is debate in the scientific community about whether it exists. Assignment writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Our expert writers have helped over thousands of local and international university students with their assignments. Every time student is stuck with their university assignments, they are very likely to search for “My Assignment Help Australia” or “Online Assignment Help”, this is where our experts come in to play.

    Assignment help
    Essay help online
    Urgent Assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  27. ABC Assignment Help is a reputed name in the online assignment services, its been four years and we have helped thousands of students with their assignments, case studies, dissertation, reports and other university assignments. Give us a chance and see Our work speak for itself.
    For further information queries visit our website Chinese Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  28. Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It's so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also.

    Data Science Course

    ReplyDelete
  29. It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it!

    Data Science Training

    ReplyDelete
  30. Helpful information. Lucky me I discovered your web site by accident!
    دوره آموزش طراحی سایت

    ReplyDelete
  31. Nice blog!! I hope you will share more info like this. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!
    angular js training in chennai

    angular js online training in chennai

    angular js training in bangalore

    angular js training in hyderabad

    angular js training in coimbatore

    angular js training

    angular js online training

    ReplyDelete
  32. du hoc canada vnsava
    Chuyên du học Canada Công ty tư vấn du học Canada nào tốt
    Điều kiện du học Canada 2021
    Học bổng du học Canada vnsava

    vnsava
    Thông tin du học Canada mới nhất

    vnsava
    Chính sách du học Canada 2020
    vnsava
    Du học Canada bao nhiêu tiền Việt
    Học bổng du học Canada 2020
    vnsava
    Du học Canada 2020
    Nhất ký du học Canada
    vnsava
    Du học Canada nên học ngành gì
    công ty tư vấn du học Canada vnsava, chính sách điều kiện định cư Canada, học bổng, chi phí, điều kiện xin visa canada
    #vnsava
    @vnsava
    vnsava
    vnsava
    vnsava

    ReplyDelete
  33. if you're trying to find a fully interactive Flash website you better be sure that the website design company you select has done many Flash websites. Jake Hackett

    ReplyDelete
  34. Great blog, thanks for sharing with us. Ogen Infosystem is a leading web designing service provider in Delhi, India.
    Website Designing Company in India

    ReplyDelete
  35. Very interesting blog. Many blogs I see these days do not really provide anything that attracts others, but believe me the way you interact is literally awesome.You can also check my articles as well.

    Rowe Rowe
    Rowe Rowe Interval

    Thank you..

    ReplyDelete

  36. Online Assignment Help
    Looking for Online Assignment Help Hire our PhD Writers from Australia for Assignment Help at Affordable Prices.Assignment Help Essay Help and Dissertation Help Services Students have a lot to bear throughout their academic life. These are the golden days of youth where you can make the distinction between how to live productively or negatively Online
    Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  37. Assignment Help Australia
    Looking for Affordable Assignment Help Australia? Hire Austraalian Experts for your University or College Assignment Help Professionals in the niche of academic writing, such as those from myassignmenthelp, understand the effort Assignment Help
    Australia writing requires

    ReplyDelete
  38. It is very interesting post! If you have facebook account you can post there too and get facebook post shares from this site https://soclikes.com/. I sometimes do this way for good post

    ReplyDelete
  39. Many companies focus on Product quality but only a few of them focus on high-quality boxes, that's why they win in the market. The packaging impresses more than the actual product to the customers.
    custom boxes with logo

    ReplyDelete
  40. Really nice and interesting post. I managed to locate decent advice out of your posts. I wish to read more about it! Cheap Custom Boxes

    ReplyDelete
  41. ViSit our website for custom boxes.
    https://procustombox.com/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Very interesting blog. Many blogs I see these days do not really provide anything that attracts others, but believe me the way you interact is literally awesome.You can also check my website as well.

    Do my online exam

    Thank you..

    ReplyDelete
  43. Nice Article! Graana.com, Pakistan's 1st Real Estate Marketplace is the one-stop solution for all your real estate needs. Real Estate App is set to change the conventional real estate industry of Pakistan into a modern, transparent, intuitive, and purposeful portal, where we will help you buy, rent, sell, or investment properties.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The way you have described about Custom Packaging, Donut Boxes, Rigid Boxes, Candle Boxes, Shoe Boxes is great, every start up business should try to get Custom boxes for their product.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Great Article. Looking great work dear, I really appreciated to you on this quality work. I would like say thanks for this post. Here are some useful links for students all across the globe. These tips may help me in the future. A high-standard post with all imperative information.
    engineering consultants in uae | villa design in dubai | interior design companies in dubai

    ReplyDelete
  46. It is a very helpful data. It will help to improve my knowledge about this topic. Thank you for this awesome post.
    dubai development authority | abu dhabi municipality approval

    ReplyDelete
  47. I have bookmarked your blog, the articles are way better than other similar blogs.
    interior design dubai

    fit out companies in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  48. Are you looking for ayurvedic consultant then don’t worry we have best Ayurvedic Doctor in Australia

    ReplyDelete
  49. Nice blog i like it very much keep up the good work.
    Lip Balm boxes

    ReplyDelete
  50. Use Copper Water Bottle because it has Ayurvedic Health Benefits, Helps In Preventing Heart Diseases and Maintaining Cardiovascular Health and many more.

    ReplyDelete
  51. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  52. A Corporate Sales Specialist operating in the Latin American region. We are experts in Mercado de Vehículos Eléctricos Híbridos|Tamano de la Industria, Participacion, Crecimiento, Informe, Analisis 2021-2026, We provide market reports across various industry verticals and also help with procurement and supply chain intelligence. By giving you better insights, we help you make informed business decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  53. A Corporate Sales Specialist operating in the Latin American region. We are experts in Mercado de Medicina Deportiva|Tamano de la Industria, Participacion, Crecimiento, Informe, Analisis 2021-2026, We provide market reports across various industry verticals and also help with procurement and supply chain intelligence. By giving you better insights, we help you make informed business decisions.

    ReplyDelete
  54. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Are you struggling with your homework? No worries, Acadecraft has the best solution. It has Educational Explainer Videos that help the students with the most complex of homework.
    The content creators develop the videos in smaller chunks. The solutions are error-free, innovative, and authentic.
    By the way, you get the quality video explainer service at an affordable price.

    Video Solutions for eLearning

    ReplyDelete
  56. I want to say thanks to you. I have bookmark your site for future updates.
    data scientist certification malaysiaa


    ReplyDelete
  57. Say good-by to sleepless evenings, tedious chores, and unfinished business. Nursing  Assignment writing assistance is a one-stop shop for all of your academic requirements. With over a decade of industry experience, we promise on-time delivery, plagiarism-free material, and research that exceeds your expectations. With our comprehensive academic package, you will never have to be concerned about any element of your academic path. get NURSING Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  58. i'm dazzled. I don't assume Ive met each body who knows as an incredible arrangement simply extra or considerably less this present circumstance as you reach. you are in goal of truth handily proficient and colossally sparkling. You thought of something that individuals ought to get and made the trouble energizing for us all. absolutely, satisfying website you have came.. Razer Surround Pro Key Generator

    ReplyDelete
  59. basically I experience your page besides practicing and helpful appraisal. it is defended colossally advantageous calculation when a combination of our assets.thanks for part. I participate in this make perceived. Tally GsT Crack

    ReplyDelete
  60. When helping students with assignments, I've found that using tools like the AI Paraphrasing Tool can significantly improve the quality of their work. It assists in rephrasing content to avoid plagiarism and enhances clarity. By incorporating this tool into their writing process, students can produce more polished and original essays, which ultimately leads to better grades and a deeper understanding of the material.

    ReplyDelete